When it comes to opinions, beliefs and ideas, we all have
them and different views and ideas about topics can lead to controversy. We have instant access at our fingertips to
information, research and news reports.
An article that I read in The Washington Post had the headline, “Researchers: Using an iPad or smartphone can harm a
toddler’s learning and social skills.”
Of course, the title of this article caught my interest because I have a
toddler and I wanted to make sure that her using a tablet or my phone is not
going to hurt her development. As I read
on, I realized that my toddler was not in great danger. I discovered that the article, by Terrence
McCoy, summarized some research that was done about young children using mobile
devices and the potential downsides, such as using iPads was detrimental to the
social-emotional development of the child. The article stated this technology
could “interfere” with a child’s growing sense of empath or problem-solving
skills.” The article also briefly mentioned
the educational benefits for iPad use for toddlers such as language acquisition
and reading ebooks.
A conclusion that I drew about this article was that I
should not expect my child (or other children) to develop strong social and empathic
skills if they are given a mobile device to use for an excessive amount of time
and on mindless activities with no person-to-person interaction. This really was not something new to me.
A second article that I read, by Pete Etchells in The Guardian, “No, research does not say
that iPads and smartphones may damage toddlers’ brains” criticized the above-mentioned
article by first pointing out that the headline did not match up to the article’s
content and then went on to say that the information provided in the article
was not research but in fact it was guidelines that were published previously
based on research. Etchells elaborated
more on the topic and pointed out conflicting results on the studies of the
topic.
The two articles appeared to be contradictory opinions
because of their headlines but actually both articles provide information from “research”
that in inconclusive which leaves both conclusions to coexist. Neither article provided sufficient enough
evidence to persuade a reader to decide who was correct about the topic.
Paul Etchells. No, research does not say that iPads and
smartphones may damage toddler’ brains. The Guardian Feb 2015.
Terrence McCoy. Researchers: Using an iPad or smartphone can harm a toddle's learning and social skills. Washington Post
Feb 2015.
I really liked the tips you posted about on your page for the beginning of the school year in a 1:1 classroom. Do you have any more specific tips for a kindergarten classroom that would work well to start off the school year?
Thanks for any input!
Sue